Ethos Publications

Navigation Menu

The Kind of Evidence to Put in a Masking DA

JFIF;CREATOR: gd-jpeg v1.0 (using IJG JPEG v62), quality = 90 C     C   @" }!1AQa"q2#BR$3br %&'()*456789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz w!1AQaq"2B #3Rbr $4%&'()*56789:CDEFGHIJSTUVWXYZcdefghijstuvwxyz ?(((((((P4bWuw5jc kG:h-e1 bmm`sU#؄R0;y,`OSvO ٽW# f8kIKAa-ot$;%Cٔ` N:+WY=GzU:h)"X`+e4ѨQE((((((((((((((((((((Yt˽bkۉ(m2I+ªbOM}>:~mu/ :gN |\>qЌVsjbm-ϒp^Ю5Yb;kU=iu'uy9SBZpziߟiE n+Hh9 Ӱ5J=jQp=ElY'n=\\596,lECsȦ57AJeM2 MC(T.S9ZG5Rp?:͒~kl5\Tcڹe@FYKa|Af|Zt|S+57U'w-.mf xfIUAcͪQ1ʞ=?|y\[LEcB7jl7'I1 VlB=#^V~lQWuΝZMc}l9B^((((((((((((((((((+g>|sM?A,TE@y$xUX $k '¯ ij(^aVO c 8VFInf٧A#tj,=Z'4V 睠Fh (W7Uw+===׎a{jLת60F?mdwqV#5v)+*N|T`{ Q90}=MA?7zR.;+ktiA}q6P 9J]f| $j>YGs u=1 O(hyMqzǨOƪ W{nkR28QAk~кČ71>~Xer{v$Odqpç\X:ꏻ~ #6~~AxLN,;xkcKeQ-`.qY]g'&_1xgoR3sFUob3U7G-qG0AF*W{'t:A{WۜҹSs'9Y_w!hRu3`5yup̖S;rO1|}tKáxQ @):ij;) J!=g;A]Fg֚ITTK3b8~1fb1}k>"i}J:fͼ  \wDW |]6_կ$Gqy>S.Àr[~ e>Z[r[EX"澒:t?G,UI;Q~g|ca$i1ɂb8=j|g|Måso#͜wyͷ+[:u]̊zyjvї!S$czBߟellޗOvgm¼t_ż {})3>vlwFO^zK#󒻸E*Y:Oa k [coh څ_'LM)W-xo|1sʇǼ #x:'[\Oԏ&k񝶽i҉FJKǽB4za0VZD薒"; qGƤgi XA w}ԸQrAȫGMZh5b$We;xRMB)` ׵AX-aYގ,=j|USww0|AV#[+5oWQtҟ?ǂmS}YlkaH:֯%0/~ UMfxgBUlucd~IWEh1湍)]-;G5lcy/ ңHֆKR}H8}N+ֵbmFyZA|Bx>}sW"Fr;z4>!E&A\WqrRӕ<;rs~-xZ7T(s+ļYOݏiZuxFx:2jZyNFIs;F;Wlm;H-Q$ǿ'Z\]+ȌJW^ vc}+4fSR[.n`r1qW+j la'׺/å.UJW'uAI)xQ=q^Uii-&+QG_nC|ׅmͲ;GWQz4>hocִkMBv]Vɟ'\rw|;nn4NqtY{SֽŞ bx䅰# F=y˶F} >r~OU9 s!BY `aڙ>~".Y`wCu Ydab0@#߼/R%d~C{}?׷~/"|?fnA;Fݏsץ ;¬O6 ރ>xkL,uxa-ACm 8b8VIZֶR$TD^0^or+j>cpLզ:|w `4~cy<@,X0*Y >G_M {wOۇL%qڶb~TOվJ5W)q4l󞃧Gb\\}n{p?^zcf'ƸZVlTӣ-:`gcU-F^/ܨᷟk'Ю!t7R#i&6_9$bҽL2Ba̍7Df\~q 35u,w5lp +Xm8ϧ8TV^fL篩ɲAθ.L8uqZ}'ATA9?x_nZX3mg#7WP?5Y88>y;Yn9+:_CJd1 j63]>:{xo⎝8VE0=?r\=2j#_ 6OJYT3קxs.fC}?^Tw $Q_p|9~`|^ Yc"YPPs8O uiiQ0snNcb2=n~wc#kk{q..4D YG$ƹVO퓝47g%5|s|Z% m s|zKgdm\9G!&gn$O~=^ox0~׭9ur08nI? n~$`eֵICS}k$/՝uefv|c"Ἰ7c9ǧJ|?Pֽ Ki_|=s:y6u4kPwFz* 7rkj}[ua*G ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (>-Vа&VbpB~}/f(|w e5YFWА UΗN j묦 4#󝣶rΖ7FMEqCJt31C)3-wcszW'{n ylgkԉ HOzwq{TZ橜}%&DRt>yii(&%'=H͔j`~i8t!+Xt8pƹ8:85ܬ`e& --,v 9=fMf }@ TN6ougf dp+友j>gl-ά[ZNֹ_/|wx/ 6٫jI ՎA ~x:M=%y)$Grv|#SvRGd|X߉湫|YB{Gz1 :`5OᵨY<hQmMFI\{@~8?moZCq&lĒu9f[gv=I'kfL7gUS{Dz إ }$bxC׎txPVˠ׺1N/Uo$@sq6#szl|{Vч+<; 7Y`ޭX,H +Wl麹c=KFr3O45OEceG=1s~SK4r)D%Y`:+i F`GLWƿxge޷/$opUkBz621ưu|9؉ҽF~#xg,u '|#/i ιI#rJ6@oHu2B^YO%p#a]sm3W+"QZQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEzOG8z6Gd$-̅S"ygВ\+C5 RтY\GsΌO~Cs7=ks / H# 9'IHZɱ[WX!Izxztޯ[~U擹Zϸ@,n #<·lzRB1o޾ͩFf8us^x5'BSp^ 0WMl}(znl}syM4>p{i00>0BѼ]?9^7@%=q؟z؂nk˴Ǵ [mK[vYbA~ԊPoCa#׃~OE[5A 2 |Of#}+ߵ=Ɲȓ:Rxugo|>Zjm{=y*{ v.r:x Clv7“cYCWW苖8>9|y_G}{0i:iГPy@ǂf?Þռc}d)lJ*ʏp9 #s㑗m|?ש4ޤb=Ir#ONk`΋Kk3/UQE| ؑŷonC}5y>O:tS('F@%?J?P\o pkOo LhFNF í}}KK$7>  ݬp]GOD B@sh)}x״S57g|.<{VU5K2ar0 TrK_szw^\(P;jS K͊ȬJkVҏS~iNGM@cN?J_Ԥǥt6q_&ϥq_𩭯Z&թXEx On--$hF=YyVq_? cI.dXlC1fiAg&X:X+SOVe .HqVlp9WRA#ֺ)Dq+Cmx_a\&C3NS21ں>8F'=ϽmY]Aڋt([l4cWcrr '5mtvҩ09 #:A)1u WU3jnK[m)~;}Ο23AQAE.U8|C*Z ͈P2H{oÎ)J1gU:z&#}ڃdb&z Uw}ΘxTZ 7Wr]ʧԔ~oA_G'/w~ø/wO[OȵV>a_v${/6Zy L=B_;./s<6 q)=ɒV8md}ZӚYbKm 7Feq`߆3g"E}%fHQ[{8zHJJ[vIxt?H8y+>{MRu*nz熴ˁ4:dMp:M12I}6Hb"Oj5;yȑvΊW#JAx298.fh۱ߎxI$29튚L4du7GG3*~*@O>[w`="9R ETdl'=*v4.mvPWCk-msMq0 ޭ[^m*:QYĒǸ`kڏ^4zkۣ6k>C߈8n=a^?&F Q;H#`m۲RB?/ ox"ϝ_zp@#G!=*X{={#'c=⺻Dž}7~ s7{q_U|Zv3ܚӳ;xup*[{<AM G #d<5RkQ GMO!i5}eTs9t}KR~8-Y<~pnen}'ķVlOwZ:lV6h#!۫}tFܪ~Gm&útz| omN:]Ep+wcM@9~kdC[vV_)Tָk=D0ܬwCj+5IzTzTMTR0T"O. NfyȬ^WAwɵ li(X\Z'ڪKy'9=jI9Kgcr+;ZGƹX.[^PX$gg:3.ua<ڹ;E U}5SB?>G8RKbW[ְ#Ea{Rcpk_MԢT33Ҝy /8Obi>=R}~%Z.Oe"2ݑtkpg`xjՑcޓא]$q軁#+ŵ'|:Ҽ>Wb=ĶM1Tdۜwx(Pꁹf>; b9pkiG "%vQy )6{?O"ͭ$2ʲ`㙯spKJU$e  _ F.R+QEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQE Pn%I{t't }Hj9cXT3|3+zׅ'iRX=iOZa=GL־gQy)8scLQ KHVf9$(C((((((((((((((((<xE Lmw!3Åa.Tk.;kxYѸ %~~~6ছ^>&1~`Fd.grq_Z({H9@kCEF28=(oHr3z}OJ`Fqj0_#=[_܂Z-'A#ݴ :R:;K}tЦzY6w`7g5e6ާ5QHĆ7n>\J }?L[1[p΍/֕: }i>pxpxTd6lv:$uxzN~n?:R&z@NFyMHSzʾ{"2ckϼK-L_Lsй>,(#C^[⏋;L sOݯ"ѵmwǷQhssJwOqswmFE!O_oOݑq9 =ƾŞMʊMfpyL)dp9%[V:={q)xBAv`w=sQr 4QEtQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEQEWgs!L1nx0dOڵփYjV2/lK%RD`gR _P?N\͖9{O=+x*jVr0|5q9II'8"zvbE|n00)UD9?T #c?,h\GY5f6h ;R3eڻO 7#aWA6рxMHߩ?fʶ"+n^|ڱ1oRU9#__HxS&`󏡮/㟆'KeOQҳC /{G2ɵ ZOź%Erd|7obkڟw:DH1+־xG4?HDp`dQZe j|ϕR) 3隹0}o6t+wE%<6U}wG={De-BH26HeXyW^:ޅ^\" tyr1A$9:.Ԝ#lvˤekd8E/0:W^ & W/,m&~a,qw/FհøWOq_^O 41+]:cr#}FY#__ o[ҵy<&*-nPbЌH28+/ZxHZn]WV_kSZ;R9kOcl!:$k"utCtǀr<+oV~) մKMsJnK.q?ϵpNy{krq{Mk9fWqhEBZkVz Wx_gL|E2M lK/ǥLc)h:u=] uSGowrnQeNS56Z?<+m*ɮ$5'dlhcBWvWs3/zgߵ7Ŀ6,מD5'6ǹf :Mu 9|Z~|i~ndMM|] 2K' + $(~z2lml&Rml.ᜌJft,X+\͞QO@b8qLx ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( ( (>k/d"Ls~?Kyhi |/ߎ+UlHC*b9#U14gl1*S=1Yi!V`h?qRq5qY (9W Vl4Uzgާ[3=*çu?8@?ӭK-$av'?2/yyʤA?z4 k"G|xr_ܘgF.Nk īs^#}W~φq,ݕ9iEѭιe O71隌}Hsᕐ_D|#A}O[ʙ}"쇶c\\;W*2A2 q^KcGPohPXXk+^@cR^}Dg⮉--#ic8s=_־T˗]y)lNg{qWxN.Z_M&ʡ|?enFFU`R@,޽O._xn:I/7s-Ó$&rzqkYo 2Z5nVi 89R8gib֗УF#*F1qRxs{FMf6kR ͯ毅MNW'~I#Д׭xsmG]&B$0mBxB2y=1_:7MÖmk1F0#P?QV=G@1X;qҴ;yiYԤ7>(q6}Yq j\~ mL& srQ5T:Ǐ^X){ywiiw8nt#oヒyzNtMRbkiZ' ?_ƿI񭞢 ?cQ1aOA}zAIs֤I ԗq+mx$FP$G*@!#j r/)|Ͻ^ { $I-?Ү$\?*͚U<}zUn˓߭bOkZ@?1͍&_lz]ib qɫ9?Lh;4SK ܧnzsyþ) Q\Bޡ8+=@^Zv;o[X@X9?Ҿm񇄮X.Lw}y#iҌ֧͟ſ R`Nxu+uy:v"߀n&ۏ;R(3_ c t4xVm8Hmsm< >fyu0{JuK{5ZS=+>*_˒Eo^]2sN߯u=ْ6=1G%[dXT 9d?%bF&GLiw>/TK g!___zhu dcڰ/gmY bs!:b $'?ZVzTO'z/ɇ\7' O'?P=J%^(3\c<['gg˞Ҳ$<[{y\~=(ǦxԤF 9zW|G% 2ECֵ4N[)yDLBP1IYJ=NVq| ^`}EzKQשk-u8 :8 ۭsq`J2EgΗQ]OkqSO?=?+CyM`FT *]Zgsppw9q_1,öG\sT 'nXFzsWNr;[@H8==iY=#G2t ? v*`6z +Sf-2H(:/r~Ml[1tn̘X.;TnR;U@! i-@8ih`SWc>}qguCqo#E,l0Uk} $Z^i˹Ț0>hEazQ eu h⭴ i?v@0մ15(C?#ZSG (@(((((((((((((((((+GBᗈk.DW֪@.+"F?²g3qǧ2hz?*Ɯɣ `y֡NH6NP,=&40X qP 2$OKmłsZb\#~5Tr?֨JRH2FT5ya ewOÊnn$[:G,d@v)*qzTB<5]xkWy]Z.H+˟P?v-ӞlPeFӚnt*ɫ3|7T !~Nm#V^Ν'.$o\SЇPDTqVy=^@?m#y+2 5i*)=kdq5fo›|otVҌ *W 0sZEGlWhm ;Tf6pb d2'3_o==| >G>2u F{l̿Xz >I שL-o<пQ?w#cROk^T/6cY ]DŽHceN(,O ]IOPGZej0(((((((((((((((((( SlenCGc)4ӶǶwEiMS?Cǭw:ow,1|mi0Դd9,fWS UcDz5d |ϥS8[^ٸ;ug+IN`8 jSg-r)v83|tw$ʺ}?PWP+LjT)Vb2Wȵգx#Oo+!<玄ֆrq#Sn9Edsʖn\Y# 5qAtS?x^OSMwnk[).$W<j0Ts\Iwǖ`GUBF#wWv:Η)he+Ͼ?z7&ʅRbT  {\ m N=DdO]A{#?99 !Y@\A]m r(R2[\c뚶|`ֲ/-).ni70s޳Vh!_%*AA3T3Ҩj*)9űSM'ŝOIIvg?g&{ڶf&F",<cmJioׯ\?`f;LsN[NUy`>3[}vg:*4gqkXj_4_SHݟlgcnG&J f pzc<prְi639"!No\j$=OƧ3T#͕Cgv/*$0zH?!uO ǯ~S%>ĂdI+B K`O :*|t_Ţ9O[][+/֪WU$ypFk63IEcf|%JS;)~a,O WSS "}pcs_ FmHC7\clWFcij&s5NF1mz\QTEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEPEP,

Posted by on Dec 20, 2010 in Debate, Featured, Research, Strategy | 3 comments

Reader Ryan Funkhouser from Washington submitted the following question: Hello! I attended the TX ethos camp this year and one of the things discussed was masking DAs. I understand the principal behind it, but I can’t find any generic evidence supporting it. Is there such evidence?…what does masking DA evidence look like and how do you...

Read More

Impact Calculus

Posted by on Dec 2, 2010 in Debate, Strategy | 1 comment

What would you say if you saw a warrior do battle and lose—because he never thought to use his strongest weapon? What would you think if you saw a chess player who refused to ever bring out his queen? And what would you think of a football coach who never threw to his receivers? Well, sometimes, this is what I see when I look at debate rounds in the NCFCA....

Read More

Overview of a Disadvantage and How to Respond

Posted by on Nov 1, 2010 in Basics, Debate, Featured, Strategy, Theory | 0 comments

I was recently asked several questions about disadvantages via emails. There will be more to come on types of disadvantages and fleshing out each of the points below, but I figure it is best to start with an overview of disadvantages and what you can say against them. Why run a disadvantage? Because it shows that an idea is BAD, for issues that...

Read More

Alternate Causality as Aff Solution

Posted by on Dec 29, 2009 in Debate, Strategy | 4 comments

So we all know that alternate causality arguments are a powerful refutation. But sometimes we forget the similar argument, which is that there is an alternate solution to neg disadvantages that mean the DA shouldn’t be considered. It isn’t run as often because if you really take the theory to the extreme, you’re basically permuting a...

Read More

Big Idea: Spending Arguments That Don’t Stink! (Alternative impacts to spending disadvantages as an introduction to nonconventional argumentation)

Posted by on Dec 26, 2009 in Debate, Strategy | 2 comments

We’ve all been there. You’re in a round against a case you’ve never seen before. Maybe it’s at an open against a team from another region, maybe a team trying out a new case, maybe it’s just one you didn’t see coming. Either way, you’re in for an interesting time. You look through your binder (or, if you’re...

Read More